Just a few decades ago, most Americans relied on pensions to fund their retirement. Employers carried the risk of a guaranteed payout, and employees had little control over how or where their money was invested.
Then came the 401(k). Introduced in 1978, it flipped the model: Employers capped their liability, while employees gained control and portability. The shift redefined financial ownership and trust in the employer-employee relationship — and, ultimately, became the dominant retirement savings vehicle by the mid-1990s.
Today, we’re on the brink of a similar revolution in health benefits: the rise of the individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement. And just like the 401(k), this change is about more than cost — it’s about decentralizing risk, empowering individuals and aligning priorities in a system that desperately needs it.
Introduced in the 1940s as a World War II-era wage-cap workaround, group health insurance was designed for a different workforce: a monolithic, centralized, one-size-fits-all labor force where employees often stayed with one employer for decades. Benefits were standardized and employers absorbed the rising costs as a simple matter of doing business.
But today’s workforce is dynamic, diverse and demands personalization. Employees switch jobs every few years and expect benefits that reflect their unique needs. Yet, more 80% of small firms offer just a single plan, leaving many — especially remote workers — underinsured and eyeing better benefits elsewhere.
Meanwhile, costs are skyrocketing. The average annual premium for employer-sponsored family coverage hit $25,572 in 2024, up 7% from the previous year and 24% over the last five years. Employers are absorbing costs and risks they’re not equipped to manage, while brokers and carriers are forced to operate in systems that resist flexibility, scale, and personalization.
Like 401(k)s redefined retirement, ICHRAs shift responsibility while expanding choice. Employers define a tax-free, fixed monthly contribution for each employee. Employees then use those funds to shop for coverage tailored to their local market and specific health needs, typically using an ICHRA platform integrated with the Affordable Care Act marketplace or private exchanges.
The number of available individual health plans varies by state and county, influenced by factors such as insurer participation. But enabling individuals to choose from locally available plans often ensures easier access to quality care from providers in their area.
This is a fundamental shift in the way health care benefits are delivered — and a restructuring that mirrors the pension-to-401(k) evolution almost exactly. Risk is decentralized. Choice is elevated. Employees are given true control over their health care decisions, and employers can offer benefits that are both sustainable and inclusive. It recasts the employer-employee dynamic: less “controlled for you,” more “collaborative with you.”
Just as financial advisors emerged as critical guides in the 401(k) transition, ICHRA positions benefits brokers to play a strategic role — helping employers design and optimize reimbursement models, forecast financial outcomes and build benefits that resonate with a diverse workforce.
For carriers, the change is equally significant. As carriers shift from group billing to thousands of individual policies, they face a ground-up reinvention beginning with a transparent, hyper-consumer-centric product design. Over time, carriers will also be forced to incorporate infrastructure for ICHRA platforms, robust payment reconciliation processes and service models built for individuals, not groups. This is not a tweak to the existing model; it’s a re-architecture of how carriers engage with both employers and individuals.
And finally, employees’ roles are redefined as well. Employees are no longer the passive recipients of one-size-fits-all plans. They’re active participants and empowered shoppers who enjoy personalization, transparency and flexibility.
It took decades for the 401(k) to eclipse pensions — and that journey reshaped not just retirement but our collective mindset about ownership, responsibility and choice. The same will be true of ICHRA. ICHRA’s momentum already is growing faster, thanks in part to support at the state and federal level. Proposed legislation like the CHOICE Arrangement Act (H.R. 3799) aims to cement ICHRA’s place in the benefits landscape, offering tax incentives and small-business credits that smooth the transition.
We’re already seeing it take shape. Employers of all sizes are adopting ICHRA to regain control of runaway premiums and serve an evolving workforce. Brokers are launching ICHRA-first practices powered by new platforms. Forward-thinking carriers are reinventing products for a consumer-driven era. And employees are finally seizing control over their benefits — sometimes for the first time ever.
The old group health insurance system won’t vanish overnight. Nor should it disappear entirely. But the direction is clear: Like the 401(k), ICHRA will revolutionize not only financial well-being but also the mental and physical health of generations to come.
We are committed to your privacy! Check out our Privacy Policy & Cookie Policy
